What CPEC can learn from KKH A new book explores the potential of the future with a historic example
Abstract
In the past few decades, the salience of geography and geo-political factors in the modernization and development of states in developing countries has been underscored in the works of Robert Kaplan, Revenge of Geography (Random House 2012), David E. Bloom and Jeffrey Sachs, Geography, Demography and Economic Growth in Africa (Brookings, 1998) and more recently Jeffrey Sachs’ critical review of Why Nations Fail: The Origins of Power, Prosperity, Poverty by Daron Acemoglu and James Robinson (Crown Business, 2012) in ‘Foreign Affairs’ (Sept/Oct 2012), titled, Government, Geography and Growth: The True Drivers of Economic Development underscore. Literature focusing in particular on theories of “new economic geography” has emphasized the role of spatial factors in contributing towards economic development and regional inequality that in turn are inextricably linked to the interaction of economies in a globalized state of affairs. Geographical factors such as territorial location, size, shape, borders and access to oceans or seas thus directly impact aspects such as development, security and formation of the nation-state. In geopolitics there are two schools of thought, one asserts that geographic location determines, the other claims it influences the security, development, formation and growth or decline of nation states. Geographical location consequently offers risks and opportunities, leading to questions such as why and how are some nation-states able to convert them into sustainable development while others suffer from uncertainties?
Brief overview:
Pakistan’s geographical position remains pivotal to its development and in that spirit
infrastructure investment could play a critical role in promoting internal harmony and
shaping its external relations. Yet precious few scholars have focused on the centrality of
‘roads’ as identity markers, drivers of competition, rivalry and connectivity among nations.
It is in this broader geo-political context that American anthropologist, Chad Haines’ book
Nation, Territory and Globalization in Pakistan Traversing the Margins (Routledge 2012,
Manohar 2016) provides some refreshing insights and interpretations on the importance of
geographical location, its role in nation-state formation and its interface with forces of
globalization.
A distinguishing feature of this research is its extraordinary focus on the Karakoram
Highway (KKH) as a centerpiece of identity, booster of China-Pakistan friendship and
promisor of economic growth and development in the case of Pakistan. Was the KKH
indeed conceived as a potential ‘game changer’? In Zulfikar Ali Bhutto’s imagination it was,
as Haines perceptively reminds us, “The KKH is two roads”—the Sinkiang-Gilgit road
connecting Pakistan with Central Asia and the national highway integrating Pakistan. It has
certainly increased mobility, connectivity and transport of goods and people, hence
transforming locale and communities. In any case, it has been China’s pioneering road
construction engineering in the mighty Himalayan peaks, a project in which Pakistan
contributed substantially. Haines’s work becomes all the more relevant and timely as
Pakistan deliberates, contests and evolves consensus on building another ‘road’: the China-
Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC).
* For further reading comment/critical feedback, please download the article
Preview PDF
Related Research
More reads connected by topic and focus.
Discussion
Join the conversation. Comments are powered by GitHub Discussions.